As of now, it's not possible to have both pagination and sort by shuffle items. As soon as you enable pagination, everything becomes fixed position, items no longer get shuffled.

This would be useful for huge listings where the intention is to show the user something new every time while also not overwhelming them with lots of items.

My use-case was to use this in the sidebar of related articles. Using pagination + finsweet load more would be awesome so the user always gets new things to explore and has the option to load more and more. Just like youtube’s sidebar when you are watching a video.